Shipshewana Part 2
HomeWork with usOlder StoriesOur ContributorsContact Us

Step Back in Time to Amish Culture in Shipshewana

Part two. This story is too big for just one post. Check here for part one.

Story and photos
by Kathleen Walls

  • The Amish refer to all non-Amish as "English." It is not meant to be offensive.

  • Bring cash as many Amish businesses do not take credit cards.

My Amish Indiana Tour with Gary Mosey

We did a day tour with Gary Mosley of My Amish Indiana. Gary and his wife, Susan, who has written several books about the communities, share their knowledge of northern Indiana's Amish communities through My Amish Indiana Tours.

Gary told us how they came to know Shipshewana so well at our breakfast at Corn Crib Cafe. I enjoyed the biscuits and gravy while one of my friends had the traditional sunny side up egg breakfast. Gary loved his breakfast bowl.

It began when Susan and a friend first visited Shipshewana for a weekend. That weekend became an annual, then twice-a-year, tradition. Susan and Gary married in 2007 and honeymooned in the Shipshewana area. Gary loved it as much as Susan, so they retired to Lagrange County in 2017, where they share their knowledge through the tours and Susan's books.

Menno-Hof Interpretive Center

Menno-Hof Interpretive Center offers the clearest introduction to Amish culture. Its exhibits trace the Mennonites, Amish, and Hutterites back to the Swiss Anabaptist movement of the 1520s.

We watched a short video, then moved through rooms that tell the story step by step. The exhibits portray the suffering early Anabaptists endured at the hands of Catholics for insisting that only adults should be baptized. That persecution drove their migration to Pennsylvania, where William Penn promised religious freedom for all.

Visiting an Amish School

Gary took us to an Amish school. Most Amish children attend only through eighth grade. The four young Amish women teachers welcomed us as the children filed out for recess.

 One teacher told us a bit about the system. She pointed to one side, "That's the side I teach. That is first grade, 4th grade, and 6th grade. I have 5 first graders; four boys and one girl. And then in the fourth grade there's only two, a boy and a girl. In the sixth grade we have five; two girls and three boys."

She pointed to the other side; "We have second grade, seventh grade, and eighth grade over here. We have seven eighth graders. We have four girls and three boys. And then in the seventh grade we have three girls and one boy. And in the second grade we have five and there's three boys and two girls."

The teachers cover every subject, with spelling, math, and English as daily staples. Children learn German from third grade on. Fridays are the favorite day because they are mostly for catching up on the week's work. We watched the children play softball outside, and when they returned to class, they sang some German songs for us.

Yoder's Meat & Cheese

We met Dustin Yoder at Yoder's Meat & Cheese. Dustin is the fourth generation in his family store. He explained how their specialty is meat, "We raise the cattle. The hogs, we work with local farmers to raise all of our hogs for us. The chicken is all done from Miller Poultry, which is all locally raised here." He's not Amish but has Amish employees and a large percent of Amish customers. The store was filled with special cheese and meats fresh cut.

E&S Sales

At E & S, we toured both the old store and the much larger one they are now in. They offer a large variety of homemade foods. A man making sushi offered us some and  we as they processed their homemade noodles.

The new store is huge like a giant Cosco and far more modern. I could get lost for days in the employee's area. When we visited, they were already stocking the shelfs and back storage areas.

The Black Sheep

Lunch at The Black Sheep with Shawna Rae was a real treat. It has a feel of Shana's days operating a food truck in its style. She gave us sample of her special sausages, wings, and burgers. All her meats are smoked. Another unique special is her Zipper Fries. Totally different and delicious.

She told us how she got to have a full liquor license, one of the few places in Shipshewana that has. "It was not fun. The process of getting it was the same process for anybody. So you apply for it, it goes to the state, and then you have to go in front of the town. The town has four board members and anybody from the town can show up...but the nice thing was a lot of the people knew a restaurant I worked at before, which is a lot of them went to, so it kind of helped because that's the environment we want to have it just be like food and beer and wine and a lot of the people knew us in the catering world so I think the fact that you knew us as people kind of helped out a little bit too, but yeah we actually got a unanimous vote with the board"

Shipshewana Buggy Rides

Buggies are a big part of Amish culture. A buggy ride should be part of any trip here. Our driver, Joni had a beautiful horse, Gracie. They drove us past many of the murals and shops downtown. My favorite mural is the one showing Heziakel Davis , the founder of Shipshewana, in the Morton Street Art Alley.

Stutzman Dairy Farm

Farming is big in Shipshewana. One farm we visited was Stutzman Dairy Farm. Harry Stutzman Jr. showed us around his dairy farm that had once belonged to his wife'
s grandmother. He really has happy cows. They are roaming free and dining on a lot of fresh hay.

He showed us through the barn area and explained the milking procedure. He gave us a sample bottle. I had a delicious chocolate milk. Harry has other animals. He tossed some food and his goats and chickens came running. 

Blue Gate

We ended out tour with dinner at the Blue Gate Restaurant and a classic night of live entertainment at Blue Gate Music Hall. Blue Gate Restaurant serves a lot of typical Amish food. I had the meatloaf and mashed potatoes. There's also a buffet of homestyle Amish entrees in another section of the building.

After dinner, we went upstairs to see Doug Church's Salute to the Stars: Remembering the Legends. It was a memorable night. David Lee portrayed Conway Twitty so perfectly you would have thought he was the real Conway and you had moved back in time. Emily Portman played Loretta Lynn and together, they preformed some of their most famous duets. She did some classic Loretta Lynn oldies. Doug Church did his impersonation of the older Elvis.

Shipshewana is a place everyone can enjoy.

 

 

 

Public Disclosure Please Read FTC has a law requiring web sites to let their readers know if any of the stories are  'sponsored'or compensated. We also are to let readers know if any of our links are ads. Most are not. They are just a way to direct you  to more information about the article where the link is placed. We have several ads on our pages.  They are clearly marked as ads. I think readers are smart enough to know an ad when they see one but to obey the letter of the law, I am putting this statement here to make sure everyone understands. American Roads and Global Highways may contain affiliate links or ads. Further, as their bios show, most of the feature writers are professional travel writers. As such we are frequently invited on press trips, also called fam trips. On these trips most of our lodging, dining, admissions fees and often plane fare are covered by the city or firm hosting the trip. It is an opportunity to visit places we might not otherwise be able to visit. However, no one tells us what to write about those places. All opinions are 100% those of the author of that feature column. 

  Search our site

  

 






 
We'd love to have you follow on social media. please use our hashtag, #ARGH 
 
Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Pinterest
Pintrest

Email us

You can order autographed copies of my books at
KatysWorld.

My newest is
American Music: Born in the USA.
Available at Amazon.






 The Tenant from Hell
Book 1 in the Realtor Mystery Series
Casey Clark, property manager, is just trying to evict a bad tenant. Instead she is over her head in murder and mayhem.
Available at Amazon

Cover of Double Duplicity

Double Duplicity
Book 2 in the Realtor Mystery Series
Trouble  follows Casey like a raging fire.
Available at Amazon

cover of Missing
Missing-- Gone but not Forgotten
Based on the unsolved abduction of a little girl in a rural  Florida Community.
Available at Amazon





coverof Under a Bloody Flag

Under a Bloody Flag
Kansas and Missouri were a "no man's land" in the days before the War between the States.
Available at Amazon









 
cover of under a black flag

Under a Black Flag
Kansas and Missouri heated to the boiling point during the War between the States. 
Available at Amazon





cover of For want of a ship
For Want of a Ship
John Roy came to New Orleans looking for peace instead he found war Available at Amazon
.





cover of last step
Last Step

Last Step will keep you on the edge of your seat and leave you gasping in surprise at the ending
.
Available at Amazon
cover of kudzu
Kudzu
Kudzu shows you a different part of the South, past and present. Mystery with a touch of romance and a smidgen of paranormal.
Available at Amazon


cover of Wild about florida south
Wild about Florida: South FL
The Everglades swarm with wildlife from birds,  to mammals, to reptiles.
Available at Amazon


cover of Wild about florida central
Wild about Florida: Central FL
Central Florida has the ocean and gulf beaches much like other parts of Florida but in many other ways it is distinct and unique. 
Available at Amazon
 


cover of Wild about florida north

 
Wild About Florida: North FL    
    Come explore caves, hills, whitewater falls and lots of other fun things you didn't expect to find in Florida. 
Available at Amazon
 


cover of georgia's ghostly getaways
Georgia's Ghostly Getaways 
Who is not fascinated by mysterious things that go bump in the night? Are there some places where departed souls still linger? Available at Amazon




cover of hosts
Hosts With Ghosts
The South has long been famous for its Southern Hospitality. Hotels throughout Dixie vie with one another to offer their guests more service and more amenities. Many have guests that never depart.
Available at Amazon



cover of finding florida's phantoms
Finding Florida's Phantoms
Florida! The land of sunshine and wide-open beaches. But even the Sunshine State has its dark secrets. Places where centuries old spirits remain tied to earth. Beneath the facade of fun and make believe lurks the real Florida.
Available at Amazon


cover of color st augustine coloring book
Color Saint Augustine
This is a way to virtually visit Saint Augustine. It's a coloring book for grown ups (but kids will love it too.)  with an actual photo of the attractions in Saint Augustine. The opposite page is the same photo converted into a black and white line image for you to to color. It's 64 pages with 30 photos and 30 pages for you to color. On each photo and each color page there is a little about the story of the image . 

 

.